The Problem with Québécois Dreamers

When I ask progressive separatists, especially those who are not members of the white francophone majority, why Quebec xenophobia exists today, they invariably tell me that it’s a function of economic stresses brought on by neoliberalism, stresses that would be gone in a socially-democratic, independent Quebec. I’m always shocked by this argument, because I really don’t think they’ve thought it through. After all, only a fool would deny that separation from Canada would, at least initially, cause a great deal of economic stress. So, if, as these progressives argue, the ugliness we see in Quebec politics is all just a function of economic stress, how much uglier would Quebec politics become during this tumultuous transition period, when economic stresses would be far more intense than they are today?

When asked about the problem of Russian antisemitism, many credulous Jewish communists insisted that it would evaporate right after the revolution. Most of them lived to regret that miscalculation, many of them paid for it with their lives. I can’t help but think of them when progressive separatists tell me Quebec xenophobia is going to evaporate soon after separation.

Be that as it may, there are those here in Quebec, and elsewhere, that view separatism as an albatross around the neck of the body politic, a bedeviling dream that distracts us from more important matters. They long for a resolution. Everything would be so great, they say, if we could just move the fuck on! Though I sometimes sympathize with this sentiment, it’s important to recognize that the dream of moving on is—itself—just another albatross. Separatism isn’t going anywhere, not in a Janis Joplin, Jimi Hendrix, Kurt Cobain sense; it’s going to fade away slowly, decade after increasingly deplorable decade, like one of those geriatric boomer bands that used to be awesome but has become a pathetic caricature of itself.

There’s little difference, at bottom, between these two statements: (1) everything would be great if we could just get over this separatism thing and move on; & (2) everything would be great if we could just separate from Canada and move on. Both positions allow you to live in a fantasy land of the future, whilst avoiding the real problems of the present. To some extent, then, they’re both akin to the worst kind of messianic thinking: namely, premillennialism.

Like many Christian fundamentalists, those who prioritize separatism or the demise of separatism, above all else, remain fixated upon a radical break with history—a world-historical game-changer—which will lead us into the Promised Land: a paradise of pristine purity, pregnant with possibility. Only there, in this latter-day Eden, can our dreams of social justice come true. Only then—after this new beginning, this fresh start—can we hope for solutions to the problems we face. But we never seem to get to then or there. Instead, we gaze off dreamily into a distant and hoped for future, while things down here in the real world go from bad to worse.

—John Faithful Hamer, The Goldfish (2016)

About John Faithful Hamer

John Faithful Hamer is a college professor who still can't swim, drive, or pay his bills on time. His sense of direction is notoriously unreliable, yet he'd love to tell you where to go. His lack of practical skills is astounding, and his inability to fix things is renowned, yet he'd love to tell you what to do. His mismanagement of time is legendary, as is his inability to remember appointments, yet he fancies himself a philosopher and would love to tell you how to live. He wouldn't survive in a state of nature, of that we can be sure; but he's doing quite well in the big city, which has always been a refuge for the ridiculous, a haven for the helpless, and a friend to the frivolous.

One thought on “The Problem with Québécois Dreamers

  1. How could you possibly come to such a simplistic and straw-man conclusion??? You’re conclusion states “Both positions…live in fantasy land of the future, whilst avoiding the real problems of the present. ”

    The reason why so many (like myself) wish we could just move the f*** on is because not moving is blocking all attempts at dealing with the present. It’s a distraction, a waste of time. No relation what so ever with dreams.

    People like me don’t believe for one minute that dreamers giving up on the separation idea would, in and of itself solve anything! That’s just stupid! Nobody believes that.

    People want this stupid debate to go away because all it does at this point is GET in the way . It only serves the two parties that have been trading power back and forth for the better part of 50 years!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s